Blinkered

20140731-184624.jpg

Lately, a couple of things have got me thinking about the concept of being blinkered, and more specifically what to do about people we come across who are afflicted by this.

Technically, as I’m sure we all know, blinkers are a contraption worn by horses to force them to focus on the road ahead, rather than be distracted by anything in their periphery vision. Extrapolating this to a business context, the initial view might be that a leader who focusses on a singular vision is a good thing. Apart from the fact that anything coming from left field can’t be anticipated. But that’s the great thing about being blinkered. If you can’t see it, it might as well not exist. So when we say someone is blinkered we mean something more like being completely closed to anything other than what is right in front of you.

My first thought is that these people need help. A horse can’t remove it’s own blinkers and neither can people. They need someone to do it for them. Of course it’s not as simple as that. It never is.

I learned this the hard way when I recently attended an interview. For once, I was not on the panel but on the other side of the table. I’d prepared on the basis that their current business plan of focussing solely on a funding stream that the government plans to re-route was questionable. Of course they did not enjoy me pointing this out. Needless to say I didn’t get a call back, and they’re forging ahead with their plan. Perhaps it was me who was blinkered, but not for long. I think I had a lucky escape.

Then yesterday I read this article in the Guardian about the evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins and his further descent into self righteousness. He’s best known for his 2006 book “The God Delusion” which decries all religion. Putting aside the horrific idiocy of the opinion expressed in his latest offensive tweet, his basic premise is that anyone who disagrees him is a moron. Now, what if it was your job (or you thought it was) to convince him that God existed? That he was fundamentally wrong?

It’s not about that essential HR skill, negotiation. That requires some room to manoeuvre, some give and take. Some compromise. It’s about a pursuit so single minded as to be completely blind to any other idea or opinion.

It’s something we all do, to varying degrees. In neuroscience terms we all have filters based on our beliefs and experiences. It’s just one of the ways we cope with the vast amount of information assaulting our senses at any given moment. As part of this model a lot of data can be ignored or discounted because it would simply be impossible to consider it all. So our individual World view means others perceive things we can’t see. It’s when this is taken to the extreme – that’s there’s an expectation that everyone should share the same World view that the worst cases of being blinkered arise.

I have wondered whether this is part of the age old battle of wills between Boards and HR about agility. Their view is that HR is being inflexible. But what if HR can see something they can’t? How do you even begin to explain something that someone refuses to see or try to understand, no matter who is actually “right”?

So I guess I was wrong. A person doesn’t need someone to remove their blinkers, because the only person who can do that is themselves. I don’t have any answers but suffice to say I don’t enjoy watching others walk blindly into a trap of their own making, no matter how culpable. So if it’s something you believe in strongly then utilise all your HR skills to influence, but also know when to give up a lost cause.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Blinkered

  1. Ian Walker

    Nice evaluation! Like many people ive witnessed this time and time again. The difficulty being if the actions of the blinkered are going to affect everyones common goal, its hard to be able to sit back and wait for thr “I told you so!” (however satisfying that option might be!)

    I read quote I liked once that went something like; “if theres absolutely no way you can win, make sure the one who will breaks records”
    So if its the blinkereds way or the high way… at least do your best to make sure the path ahead of the horse is clear!

    The problem is though, those with blinkered ideas tend to see advice as criticism of their idea… so for all they may reach their goal, the path behind them may still need sweeping too!

  2. Pingback: Best Blogs 1 Aug 2014 | ChristopherinHR

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s